Save money—book now
up to 10%
lower than Booking.com
Sunset Beach Shelter Island Amenities photoSunset Beach Shelter Island Exterior photoSunset Beach Shelter Island Exterior photo

Welcome to Sunset Beach – Shelter Island

•
8.2|Great
Check rooms and rates
From$596 /nightOnly on Our Website-10%
Check-in
16Nov
Check-out
17Nov
Guests
2 Guests
Key details

About the Hotel

35 Shore Road, Shelter Island, 11965
-
Next to the idyllic beach
Great
8.2
8.7
/10
3.9
3.5
/5

4-star beachfront hotel on Shelter Island

Location

Sunset Beach is positioned directly on the shores of Shelter Island, providing guests immediate access to miles of sandy beaches and scenic waterfront views. With its proximity to major attractions, guests can easily explore local shops, restaurants, and nightlife. The hotel's strategic location allows for convenient ferry access to neighboring islands and the mainland, enhancing the travel experience.

Rooms

The hotel offers 29 well-appointed guest rooms, including beach cottages and luxurious suites. Each room features fresh coastal decor, some with stunning ocean views, fully equipped kitchens, and private patios or balconies. Guests also benefit from amenities such as in-room dining services and customizable bedding options.

Dining

On-site dining includes the Sunset Beach Restaurant, which specializes in fresh seafood and farm-to-table dishes. The restaurant features a casual yet refined atmosphere with outdoor seating that overlooks the beach and sunset views. Guests can also enjoy a curated selection of local wines and signature cocktails at the integrated bar.

Wellness

The hotel emphasizes wellness with options such as yoga classes on the beach and access to nearby hiking trails. Guests can unwind with complimentary beach chairs and umbrellas for a full day of relaxation by the shore. The wellness program also includes access to water-based activities like kayaking and paddleboarding.

Family-Friendly Amenities

Sunset Beach accommodates families with spacious rooms designed to comfortably fit extra guests. The hotel provides cribs and rollaway beds upon request, ensuring that families have all necessary amenities. Outdoor activities are available for children, encouraging exploration and playtime on and near the beach.

Highlights

Location: Direct beach access with scenic waterfront views

Rooms: 29 well-appointed guest rooms and beach cottages

Dining: Sunset Beach Restaurant featuring fresh seafood

Wellness: Yoga classes and outdoor activities

Family-Friendly: Spacious rooms and amenities for children

“This intimate, 20-room property transports one to a South of France sensibility, where the beachfront restaurant and bar serve as the undeniable hub of activity. Rooms embrace a simple, comfortable beach-shack aesthetic, complete with private balconies, while the staff, notably Nejla, goes above and beyond to ensure guest satisfaction. The allure extends to complimentary loungers on the pristine beach and a curated boutique, making a stay here feel effortlessly indulgent.”
Hotel logo
James DavidEditor-in-Chief at Boutiquehotel

Price and Room Availability Calendar

Check availability and prices for your dates now!

Facilities

Boutique hotels design their amenities with your relaxation and unique travel experiences in mind

General

  • Non-smoking rooms
  • Free internet access
  • 24-hour reception
  • Pets allowed
  • Children are welcome
  • Luggage storage
  • Exterior corridors
  • Smoke detectors

Sports & Fitness

  • Golf course

Services

  • Room service
  • Wake up service
  • Bell staff/Porter

Dining

  • Restaurant
  • Bar/Lounge area

Business

  • Meeting room

Room features

  • Air conditioning
  • Dressing area
  • Ironing facilities

Bathroom

  • Hair dryer

Media

  • Flat-screen TV
  • Direct dial telephone
  • CD player
  • AM/FM alarm clock

Room decor

  • Carpeted floor
Show more

Location

35 Shore Road, Shelter Island, 11965
Map view
Nearby
Sunset Beach
800 ft
Venture Out Shelter Island Paddle Board Rentals
1100 ft
Beach
Crescent Beach
1800 ft
Restaurants
The Pridwin Restaurant
3000 ft
81 Shore Road
Explore Shelter Island
Local Highlights Near Sunset Beach
  • Top Attractions
  • Activities
  • Dining
  • Entertainment
Sunset Beach
3 minutes' walk
Beautiful sandy beach with stunning sunset views. Ideal for sunbathing and water activities.
Shelter Island Country Club
Shelter Island Country Club
10 minutes' walk
A picturesque golf course featuring lush landscapes. Perfect for golf enthusiasts seeking a relaxing day.
Sylvester Manor Educational Farm
Sylvester Manor Educational Farm
25 minutes' walk
Historic farm offering educational tours. Unique farm-to-table experiences and events, including local harvests.
Our Lady of the Isle Church
15 minutes' walk
Charming chapel known for its beautiful architecture and serene ambiance. A peaceful spot for reflection.
Kayaking at Sunset Beach
3 minutes' walk
Kayak rentals available offering thrilling water adventures. A fun way to explore the coastline!
Yoga at Mashomack Preserve
10 minutes' drive
Yoga sessions in a tranquil nature setting. Reservations recommended; perfect for relaxation and rejuvenation.
Biking the Shelter Island Trail
10 minutes' drive
Multi-use trail ideal for biking. Rent bicycles nearby for an exciting adventure through scenic landscapes.
The Pridwin Restaurant
The Pridwin Restaurant
11 minutes' walk
A coastal dining experience with fresh seafood and local flavors. Reservations recommended for dinner.
Sunset Beach Restaurant
3 minutes' walk
Casual beachside restaurant featuring burgers and tropical drinks. Great views with a relaxed atmosphere.
Frank's Seafood Market
5 minutes' drive
Popular spot for fresh casual dining with live music weekends. Family-friendly vibe; no reservations needed.
Dering Harbor Marina
30 minutes' walk
Scenic marina with boat rentals and fishing excursions. Perfect for outdoor enthusiasts and nature lovers.
Getting around
  • City Centre
    Shelter Island 2 min  ·  400 ft
  • Airports
    Long Island MacArthur (ISP) 127 min  ·  52.5 mi
    Republic (FRG) 170 min  ·  70.2 mi
Looking for special rates when booking early?
Explore them with us!
Check Rates
Property information and rules
Check-in
from 16:00-23:59
Check-out
until 11 am
Internet
Wireless internet is available in the entire hotel for free.
Pets
Pets are allowed on request.
Year renovated:
2010
Number of rooms:
20

Reviews and Ratings

Real comments from travelers who have already stayed
Pros
Waterfront location
Clean rooms
Breakfast options
Friendly staff
Cons
Small rooms
Dated decor
Limited parking
Noisy neighbors
Guest reviews
based on 8 reviews
8.2/10
No reviews yet on our siteUnfortunately, our guests have not yet left any reviews for this hotel, but you can read reviews from Booking.com.
Open reviews
FAQs
About Sunset Beach
What time is check-in and check-out at Sunset Beach?
Check-in time is 16:00 and check-out time is 11:00.
How far is Sunset Beach from Long Island MacArthur Airport?
Sunset Beach is 53 mi from Long Island MacArthur Airport.
What amenities are provided in the rooms at Sunset Beach?
Each modern room is equipped with an iPod docking station, a DVD player, climate control, and a flat-screen LCD TV.
Is there beach access available at Sunset Beach?
Guests can spend the day on the private beach exclusive to hotel guests.
What dining options are available at Sunset Beach?
Sunset Beach features an on-site restaurant that serves French cuisine in a casual atmosphere.
What are some nearby attractions to Sunset Beach?
Nearby attractions include Crescent Beach (1 mi) and the Fireboat Firefighter Museum (3 mi).
What recreational activities does Sunset Beach offer?
Sunset Beach offers yoga sessions and in-room massages for guests' wellness.
Is Sunset Beach pet-friendly?
Sunset Beach is a pet-friendly property that offers grooming services.
What languages are spoken by the staff at Sunset Beach?
The staff at Sunset Beach speaks multiple languages to assist guests.

Next best alternative

Consider them for your next trip.