Shelter Island Heights Boutique Hotels

Every hotel in Shelter Island Heights, United States is carefully verified and handpicked for your stay.

Check-in
03Nov
Check-out
04Nov
Guests
2 Guests
Shelter Island Heights features popular spots like Crescent Beach, the Shelter Island Country Club, and the charming Sunset Beach. You can enjoy kayaking, golfing, or simply lounging at the beaches. The area offers a great selection of cozy inns and waterfront hotels, known for stunning views and local experiences. Each option is carefully selected based on quality and guest reviews. To maximize your stay, consider booking in advance, especially during summer, and explore by renting bikes or using local shuttles.
All filters
1-1 out of 1
Sort by:high popularity
  • Price: low to high
  • Price: high to low
  • Guest rating: high to low
  • Popularity: high to low
8.6
Great
Map100 yd from City Centre700 yd from Dering Harbor Marina
FromUS$ 420 /nightSelect

Places to stay near Shelter Island Heights

Shelter Island1 hotel

7.8
Very good
1600 yd from City Centre
FromUS$ 596 /nightSelect

Sag Harbor1 hotel

8.4
Great
6.5 mi from City Centre
FromUS$ 219 /nightSelect

Montauk1 hotel

8.4
Great
22.1 mi from City Centre
FromUS$ 329 /nightSelect

Greenport1 hotel

8.4
Great
American Beech Hotel - Greenport
1.4 mi from City Centre
FromUS$ 321 /nightSelect

Prices table for hotels in Shelter Island Heights

We are happy to offer accommodations for every travel style and budget.

⬆️ The highest price
USD 420
⬇️ The lowest price
USD 420
💸 Average price for
4-star hotels
USD 420

Finest boutique hotels across Shelter Island Heights

Insights and ratings from travelers who stayed

Charming historic seaside escape:
Upscale waterfront dining experience:
Tranquil beachfront retreat with stunning sunsets:

Stay Hacks: Shelter Island Heights

Make your visit to Shelter Island Heights unforgettable with these insider tips and local secrets.

Fast Fact: Did you know? Around 60% of Shelter Island Heights hotels prioritize sustainability, like Baron's Cove which features eco-friendly practices.

Local Hack: Request a complimentary bike rental at your hotel to explore nearby scenic routes. It's a great way to enjoy the island at your own pace.

Hidden Gem: Check out the Shelter Island Historical Society's Havens House (12 mins from the main hotel district) to see local artifacts and learn about the island's rich past.

Smart Tip: Booking during mid-week can save you up to 20% compared to weekend rates, especially in the peak season.

Other cities in United States